I hoped that the assets of Delloyd, especially the Sungai Rambai Estate and the estates in Indonesia would be revalued. That has indeed happened.
I also wrote:
"The independent adviser for this corporate exercise is Affin Investment Bank. I would love to see them write something along the lines: "we estimate that the RNAV per share is around RM 15, therefore we find the proposed price not fair and not reasonable". Will they write that? Although independent advice has been improved significantly, I don't think that will happen."
Indeed, that has not happened.
Affin came up with a SOPV (Sum Of Parts Valuation) of RM 7.60. Since the offer price of RM 5.15 is a 32% discount to that valuation, the offer is deemed to be "not fair".
However, Affine still thinks the offer is "reasonable", hence their verdict: "not fair but reasonable, accept the offer". The rather ambiguous judgement that is quite common these days for independent advisers reporting on deals related to Bursa listed companies.
The most important part of the report is probably this:
Are both assets indeed worth only about RM 320M? I have read much higher valuations than that.
The problem that I have in general with many of the privatisation exercises on Bursa is:
- Why are so many offers "not fair", is it not the duty of the Board of Directors to try to get an offer that is "fair" to all shareholders?
- Why is there almost never a competing offer? In this case, Delloyd could have tried to sell its estates individually, to check if there is an interest in them, and if so, at what price. If the price is indeed good, then it could propose to sell the asset and distribute the proceeds to all shareholders. Has the Board of Directors actively tried to find buyers for its assets?
I guess nobody will take care the interest of minority shareholders, and this is one of the reason for me try not to invest in companies which having more than 50% controlled by the major shareholder.ReplyDelete
I agree that if major shareholder controls more than 50%, there will not be a hostile take over, so that limits things.ReplyDelete